Plot is Optional

Episodes

January 2026 Break Announcement

Hey PiO pals! Just a heads up that Alli and Trey will be back in February 2026 for more smut-loving pod fun with all new episodes of Plot is Optional. We have some things to do to get ready to serve it to you hot in the new year. We are excited about what is […]

Read More...

Episode 24: Soul Eater by Lily Mayne

Jo returns, joining Alli and Trey as they take a foray into monster f-ing with Lily Mayne’s Soul Eater. This episode covers Louisiana accents, hot boy meters, and the nuances of body fluids in smut. Your PiO pals also crunch the numbers and give you the tight ball count stats you crave. Enjoy this extra-long […]

Read More...

Listen on...

Episode 23: Sins of the Orc by Finley Fenn

Alli explains orc culture while Trey tries to forget all the times that this book talks about scents. They are diving into a fantasy romance novella this week with full orc on orc action. Trey finds out what clan of orcs he would be. And, of course, they touch on mage fingering, anal reiki, and […]

Read More...

Listen on...

Episode 22: A Pebble For Lewis by Amy Bellows

Alli and Trey dive into the omegaverse like a penguin into the sea. They discuss the intricacies of shifter culture both penguin and polar bear, omegaverse anatomy, and mpreg with eggs. So get into your tux, polish your resumé, and have your pebbles ready because it is pebble gifting season! Music by Cody & Alex

Read More...

Listen on...

Episode 21: Cubs And Campfires by Dylan Drakes

Alli and Trey ask the tough questions. How can a ginger tan? Why is beer the standard can of comparison? Can a life on the move make you seem 5 years older than your actual age? How many times can Trey accidentally hit his mic boom during a single recording? All this and more as […]

Read More...

Listen on...

Episode 20: The Bro and The Barkeep by AJ Truman

Alli assures Trey that this week’s read is not problematic as they dive zucchini first into the final installment of the Single Dads Club trilogy. And no, you didn’t miss any episodes. Sometimes at PiO, we eat dessert without dinner. Sometimes, that dessert is a bear dad who falls in love with the new employee […]

Read More...

Listen on...

Episode 19: Proficiency Bonus by Charlie Novak

Alli and Trey keep it short and sweet this time around, yet manage to ramble all the same. They discuss the final book of the Roll for Love trilogy by Charlie Novak. They talk Pokémon, body fluid ballistics, ADHD in a capitalist society, and non-linear space. Music by Cody & Alex

Read More...

Listen on...